I was just discussing with some doctors and with some of my ex-medical colleagues yesterday in our WhatsApp chat group that drug-based medicine fails miserably in managing most chronic diseases due to nutritional lifestyle, environmental exposures, occupational insults among other external and internal factors. Here's a comic illustration:
I discussed with them drugs do not cure
lifestyle diseases if we are unwilling to change the way we eat and live. Most
patients take the easy path by swallowing pills than modifying their lifestyles
such as managing their body weight, some are pathologically obese, others smoke
and drink, yet others lead a sedentary life and is easily upset by the
slightest stress among many other causative factors. They depend only on pills,
tablets and surgery as a panacea for all their disorders and ills with
each follow-up appointment their medication needed to be titrated to higher and
higher dosage to the maximum only to be substituted by another as adjunct.
Other medication needed to be added for
other emerging linked diseases till they and all their drugs do them part into
death. This is the sad scenario for most of the drug-dependent chronic
disorders because they refuge to change the ways they live their lives,
especially dietary and nutritional lifestyles.
In medicine non-compliance by patients to
take the prescribed medication is already one of the problems. This may be due
to many reasons, such as social, cultural and economic reasons, taboos, belief
systems, forgetfulness, too much medication to take especially by the elderly.
These factors for non-compliance are mostly unknown or ignored by the
clinician, let alone the much more difficult path to follow by changing or
modifying patients' lifestyles to replace drugs.
However, there is a moderately long list
of essential emergency drugs that are very life-saving and crucial in emergency
situations that cannot be replaced by lifestyle changes or other alternative,
complementary or traditional systems of medicine.
Let us have a very brief tour on some of
these rapid-acting drugs used in emergency situations. Let us just very briefly
run through the list. The emergency drugs are:
lignocaine, propranolol, verapamil,
digoxin, inotropic agents such as adrenaline, aminophylline, atropine,
diazepam, dopamine, flumazenil, glucose, isoprenaline. Other useful drugs are
morphine sulphate, naloxone, nitro-glycerine, nitroprusside, pancuronium
bromide, dobutamine, chlorpromazine, ipratropium, corticosteroids, phenytoin,
potassium chloride.
Listing further are protamine sulphate,
salbutamol, sodium bicarbonate, intravenous fluids such as 0.9 % normal saline,
fluid expanders such as dextrose 3% with 0.3 saline, Hartmann’s solution, fluid
expanding solution (e.g., Haemaccel, Gelofusin), including colloids for
patients with hypovolaemic shock in association with crystalloid solutions.
Lignocaine for example is recommended for
the treatment of ventricular fibrillation and ventricular tachycardia; atropine
is used in the treatment of asystole and severe bradycardia. It acts to block
the effects of the vagus nerve on the heart.
Sodium bicarbonate is used to treat the
metabolic acidosis associated with cardiac arrest.
Our list can go on, but this short list
will do as they are just examples. They will suffice for us to know how
important, and lifesaving fast-acting drugs are in emergency situations.
But let us give ourselves just one
example. Let us take a heart attack as the most common one even any lay person
is aware of.
Let us say we are confronted by a cardiac
emergency? A person has a heart attack or even a total cardiac arrest. What
shall a doctor or even a well-trained and well qualified licensed paramedic
with 4 -years of structured training in pre-hospital emergency care would do.
We shall discuss this shortly.
Cardiac emergency is just one of the many
types of medical crisis. They can range from anything from cardiac
arrest, hypertensive encephalopathy, eclampsia, phaeochromocytoma, aortic
dissection.
Others are respiratory emergencies like
acute ventilatory failure, spontaneous pneumothorax, primary and secondary
pneumothorax, tension pneumothorax, haemothorax re-expansion pulmonary oedema,
acute severe asthma, respiratory distress syndrome, massive haemoptysis, acute
gastrointestinal emergencies such as GIT haemorrhage, variceal haemorrhage,
hepatic encephalopathy, acute pancreatitis.
Listing further are metabolic emergencies
to include diabetic comas, hypoglycaemia, diabetic ketoacidosis, hyperosmolar
hyperglycaemic non-ketotic coma, hypernatremia, hypercalcemia, hypocalcemia,
Addisonian crisis, hypomagnesemia, hypophosphatemia, lactic acidosis, uraemic
crisis.
Then we also encounter neurological
emergencies such as subarachnoid haemorrhage, head injuries, acute myelopathy,
myasthenia gravis, to haematological emergencies such as severe anaemia, severe
neutropenia, fat embolism syndrome, massive pulmonary embolism, acute limb
ischaemia, acute mesenteric embolism.
Listing down other medical emergencies
include, anaphylaxis, acute auto-immune emergencies such as cerebral lupus,
down to acute poisoning from overdose of drugs, poisoning from swallowing
detergents, bleaches, disinfectants, salicylate, barbiturates, organophosphate,
carbamate, insecticide, paraquat, paracetamol, opium alkaloids and morphine,
benzodiazepines, and methanol poisoning.
Other medical emergencies may include,
but not limited to, are acute life-threatening infections like septicaemia and
septic shock from streptococcal, gram-negative bacillus septicaemia, malaria,
tetanus, dengue, melioidosis, all the way down to other medical crises from
near drowning to heat disorders like heat cramps, heat exhaustion, heat stroke
to snake bites, etc, etc.
There are other medical emergencies too
besides what we have briefly listed here that need to be considered, and it is
outside the scope of this very short article to even list them partially, let
alone discuss their treatment using drugs and other adjunct therapies.
Let us now go back to what we mentioned
earlier that the most known emergency event of all is a heart attack or
myocardial infarction or even more serious a total cardiac arrest.
Let us use only this example most
lay people are aware of, and how drugs come in very useful and lifesaving,
besides other non-pharmacological interventions such as CPR. Let us discuss
only this emergency.
During a myocardial infarction, commonly
called a heart attack there are three things we need to consider, namely:
airways, breathing and circulation (ABC). If the heart stops beating or just
quiver (fibrillating) we need to perform cardiopulmonary resuscitation (CPR)
immediately besides maintaining patent airways with head tilt, chin lift.
We need to initiate mouth-to-mouth
resuscitation with rescue breath in the prehospital environment, and in the hospital
environment, ventilate with 100 % oxygen through air viva and intubate via oral
route. Ventilate through downstroke at every 5th chest
compression, namely, 12 to 15 ventilation per minute.
Next, we need to establish circulation by
external cardiac massage at the rate of 60 compressions per minute by
transmitting heel of hand compression at sternum 2 fingerbreadths above the
xiphisternum without pausing for ventilation.
Open cardiac massage may be considered if
there is a cardiothoracic surgeon available.
Defibrillate if VT or VF serially with
200, 300, then 360 joules of shock. If no ECG rhythm gives blind DC shock since
VF collapse rhythm is common. If cardiac rhythm is established after successful
defibrillation, give lignocaine infusion to maintain.
All essential drugs should be given
through the central line or through antecubital vein reserving intratracheal or
intracardiac routes as the last option. Emergency drugs of choice for asystole
is 1:10,000 adrenaline 10 ml given bolus, repeat every 5 minutes. This drug can
cause fine VF to coarse VF more suitable for defibrillation.
Lignocaine is indicated for VT to be
given at 50 to 100 mg bolus.
Giving Sodium bicarbonate is debatable
and may not be suitable since acidosis may be reversed through adequate
ventilation.
In acute myocardial infarction this
should be differentially diagnosed from pneumothorax, aortic dissection, acute
pulmonary embolism and pericarditis. Management includes total bed rest in CCU,
intranasal oxygen at 2 litres per minute, maintaining IV access with slow
infusion, IV morphine 3 -5 mg titrated to 10 – 15 mg for pain management.
Sedate with oral benzodiazepine such as
diazepam at 6 mg tds. Antiplatelet agents such as aspirin (100- 300 mg) om may
be indicated. Betablockade such as propranolol 40 mg tds may be considered.
Other areas of intervention to be considered are diltiazem 30 mg tds for non-Q
infraction.
Thrombolytic therapy with streptokinase
1.5 megaunit or rTPA 100 mg at 10 mg bolus, 50 mg first hour, 20 mg in 3rd hour
can be considered in define Q-wave infarction for age below 75 years, with no
risk factor for bleeding, example recent surgery, prolonged CPR and no history
of allergy or streptococcal infections.
These are just some examples where
essential emergency drugs become very lifesaving. There is no other system of
medicine that can match conventional pharmacological interventions in medical
emergency events such as in a cardiac emergency.
We have very briefly outline in point
form other medical emergencies where conventional drug-based medicine is
beatable by other systems of medicine.
Unfortunately drug-based medicine fails
badly in all other lifestyle and age-related diseases such as obesity, type 2
diabetes, high blood pressure, CVA (stroke), asthma and Chronic Obstructive
Pulmonary Diseases (COPD), cancers, dental disease, heart, liver and renal
failures, mental disease, osteoporosis, and other diseases due to dietary
lifestyles and other unhealthy causative factors such as smoking, physical
inactivity, stress, anger and personality disorders among others.
I hope we have high-lighted how certain
drugs whose pharmacodynamics are very fast acting and clinically very efficient
in managing very acute medical events that will open our eyes that no other
medical system can replace.
Unfortunately, drugs are synthetic and
most fail miserably in managing most other chronic and degenerative diseases of
lifestyles where the root causes are never addressed, preventive medicine and
health education are largely ignored by clinicians.
This is where other medical systems such
as naturopathic medicine, nutritional medicine far surpassed conventional drug-based
medicine, and that is where they take over to replace drug-based medicine
effectively and permanently.
Health care is an integrated system not
based only on monotherapy of an isolated modality. Nutrition and lifestyles
take precedence over drugs for the prevention of chronic diseases.
Hippocrates, the Father of Medicine said:
"Let food be thy medicine”.
He has never said: Let medicine be thy
food?? This was put into his mouth after he was long dead.
I hope this is helpful to clinicians and
medical doctors and also to practitioners of other systems of medicine.
jb lim
No comments:
Post a Comment