The Dual Symphony of Existence on Matter,
Soul, and the Question of Human Continuity (Part 2)
by:lim ju boo - Chinese name - lin ru wu (林 如 武)
I wrote an article for my brother-in-law here:
https://scientificlogic.blogspot.com/2026/05/the-unseen-soul-invisible-dimensions.html
Let us continue on this discussion.
Human existence has long been understood through two complementary lenses: the material and the immaterial, the visible and the unseen. Science explores the structure and behavior of matter, while philosophy and theology grapple with meaning, consciousness, and identity. Between these domains lies a profound question: Is there something within us that transcends the physical body?
Let me propose a reflective hypothesis, one that does not claim experimental proof, but seeks coherence between analogy, theology, and scientific understanding.
1. The Analogy of the Negative and the Image
In the earlier days of photography, images were produced using negatives. These negatives contained the complete informational structure of a photograph and could be used repeatedly to reproduce identical positive prints anywhere in the world so long as we still have the photographic negative with us. The film negative represents our soul, and the positive print of our photo represents our physical body. Both must exist together to make us what we are - the body with a soul - the living breath of God. No sane person, including the highest trained scientist can deny this. Let me expand on my thoughts further which is my hypothesis even though we are unable to prove this with experimental data - because we live in a physical world. The "negative film" belongs to the spiritual world in another dimension that we are unable to cross over because there is a deep chasm between between these two worlds.
In many traditions, this chasm is described as a vast gulf, abyss or a fixed barrier that cannot be crossed in either direction in those in the afterlife cannot return in the living, and the living cannot cross cannot enter the realm of the dead.
Ancient Greek description of the afterlife (Hades or Tartarus) often include a chasma mega which is a giant chasm that functions as a barrier or a dark, shadowy path that separates the dead from the the world of the living.
In the parable of the rich man and the Lazarus, Jesus too reveal the us exactly the same as given in (Luke 16:26).
Hence, it is impossible for scientists like us to cross over this deep chasm between the physical and the spiritual worlds with our instruments to observe, let alone measure what's going on the other world. We can only sense this logically through revelation. This clearly tell us we cannot even feel there is a spiritual half (the soul) in all of us as long as we remain living and physical.
This analogy offers a useful framework for understanding human existence:
1. The physical body is like a printed photograph - visible, tangible, and temporary.
2. The soul may be likened to the photographic film negative - an enduring blueprint that preserves identity.
The printed image may fade, tear, or be destroyed. Yet as long as the negative exists, the image can be recreated. This film negative can be kept as long as possible and brought to any other town, city or even to another foreign country not our own where an exact positive photographic image of ourselves can be produced. Its like our soul in a form of a negative film where we may travel to appear in an exact form in another foreign world when we leave this world on death. We need only carry our soul as a negative film where a positive image of ourselves can easily be developed, namely, in another world when we die a physical death here in this world.
Similarly, the human body is subject to aging, decay, and eventual dissolution into the elements from which it arose. But if there exists a non-material essence, a “negative”, it may serve as a carrier of identity beyond physical death.
2. The Biblical Perspective: Breath and Dust
This duality is echoed in the scriptural account found in Genesis 2:7:
“And the LORD God formed man of the dust of the ground, and breathed into his nostrils the breath of life; and man became a living soul.”
Two components are described:
1. Dust of the ground — the material body
2. Breath of life — the animating principle
The body alone does not constitute life. It becomes “living” only when infused with this breath. One may interpret this breath as more than a biological function—it may represent a non-material essence, a soul.
3. Rebirth and Continuity of Identity
In the New Testament, the encounter between Nicodemus and Jesus introduces the concept of being “born again”—a transformation that is not merely physical but spiritual - the presence of a soul.
This suggests continuity beyond the present form. If the body is transient, then whatever is “reborn” must be something that persists beyond bodily decay.
Within the framework of the earlier analogy, it is the “negative”—the soul—that carries forward the blueprint of identity into another mode of existence.
4. A Scientific Reflection: The Journey of Matter
Modern astrophysics provides a striking parallel narrative regarding the origin of our physical bodies.
The astronomer Carl Sagan popularized the idea that humans are made of “star-stuff.” The elements essential to life—carbon, nitrogen, oxygen, calcium, and iron—were forged in the cores of ancient stars and dispersed through supernova explosions.
This idea was earlier anticipated by Harlow Shapley and is frequently reiterated by Neil deGrasse Tyson, who emphasizes that our atoms are traceable to cosmic origins.
Thus, even from a purely scientific standpoint, our physical existence is not confined to Earth. The matter that constitutes our bodies has already undergone a vast journey across space and time. Similarly, we may take another outward journey to another star (world) when we die here.
I have also written an article we may have come from another world after being blown here as star dusts, for God to blow into these dusts to make us as a living souls for us to stay here temporary:
The Brevity of Human Life:
https://scientificlogic.blogspot.com/search?q=we+are+made+of+star+dusts
5. Beyond Measurement: The Limits of
Science
Science depends on observation, measurement, and reproducibility. Yet not all meaningful concepts are directly measurable.
The soul does not appear to interact with instruments in a way that allows for direct detection. However, this limitation does not necessarily invalidate its existence. In science it does not mean if we are unable to see, detect or measure an entity that entity does not exist
Science itself often begins with theoretical constructs. A notable example is Hawking radiation, proposed by Stephen Hawking. This phenomenon arises from quantum effects near the event horizon of black holes and remained undetected for decades after its prediction.
Once again, such examples remind us that absence of evidence is not always evidence of absence, especially when dealing with phenomena at the boundaries of current knowledge.
6. A Philosophical Synthesis
If we bring these strands together, a possible synthesis emerges:
1. The body is material, transient, and derived from cosmic matter.
2. The soul, if it exists, may function as a carrier of identity.
3. Death represents not necessarily annihilation, but separation of these components.
Within this framework, the soul may be seen as preserving the informational essence of a person, analogous to a negative preserving an image.
Whether this essence is ever reconstituted into another form remains beyond scientific verification, but it is a hypothesis that blends with both theological teachings and philosophical reasoning.
7. The Question That Remains
The question of the soul ultimately lies at the intersection of science, philosophy, and belief.
Science tells us what we are made of.
Philosophy asks what it means.
Faith suggests why it matters.
I believe my analogy of the photographic negative offers a powerful way to bridge these domains. It does not claim proof, but it invites reflection.
And perhaps, in matters such as these, reflection is the beginning of understanding.
Extension of My Previous Original Thought
Briefly explained, the analogy the presence of a soul in us and in all living creatures further is this way:
If the soul is analogous to a “negative” carrying the blueprint of identity, then it may not merely preserve structure, it may also encode memory, consciousness, and moral imprint.
This raises deeper questions:
1. Is consciousness an emergent property of
the brain, or is the brain a receiver of a deeper essence?
2. Does the “blueprint” include not only form, but experience?
3. Could moral and spiritual development influence the “quality” of this blueprint?
4. As we grow up in life we take many photos of ourselves with mistakes and sins we committed along the way without us knowing it. The latest photo of ourselves will be displayed for our funeral. Those series of photos together with their negatives will be used for or against us as evidences whether we change from our mistakes or repent for our sins. They will be photographed as our spiritual negatives to be printed and copied in our next world. Such questions move us toward the idea that human life is not only biological but informational and experiential, with continuity that may extend beyond physical existence.
Once again, human beings may be understood as consisting of two parts:
1. A physical body, made from earthly and cosmic materials
2. A non-physical essence (soul), which may carry identity
Using the analogy of a photographic negative:
3. The body is like a printed photo—temporary and perishable
4. The soul is like the negative—preserving the blueprint of who we are
5. Taking care of our souls that is "negative photographic film" of our ourselves is exceedingly far, far more important than just taking care of our temporary physical body and physical health here that last at maximum 100 years, for it is from our souls that is eternal that many, many copies of ourselves can be reprinted as evidences for us be saved in the next world, or condemned into the eternal Lake of Fire when we leave this world.
If we live aggressively with anger, selfishly accumulating great physical wealth all the time - all of them we will instantly be forced to leave behind on death.
Many exist here without love, charity and compassion for anyone, without sharing anything at all, do not wish to acknowledge the presence of God who breathe into us a living soul.
Science shows that our bodies come from star matter, while theology suggest that life comes from a divine breath. Although the soul cannot be measured scientifically, it may still be a reasonable hypothesis to explain consciousness and identity.
It is almost impossible for scientists to prove spiritual entities and dimensions they cannot see or measure because of this great chasms, except revealed to us as I have already earlier explained.
Even for physical entities such as dark matter that constitute about 85 % of all matter in the universe, 68 % of the total energy in the cosmos are dark energy, as well as neutrinos, primordial gravitational waves that ripples in spacetime created during the Big Bang - all of them are extremely difficult to detect. So are quantum and subatomic such as axion that are hypothetical ultra-lightweight particles or quantum entanglement / fluctuations - all of them belonging to our physical world.
If we find it so difficult to detect these entities that are physical, how much more difficult it would it be to cross over a deep chasm separating the physical and the spiritual worlds for us to know what exist in the other dimension? They can only be revealed to us in scriptures as I have already quoted several verses on this.
A very few of us like myself have very strong intuition to feel beyond - something constantly telling me their presence for me to express to share here.
However, for most other scientists they use their trained and qualified knowledge as a springboard to logically build up a hypothesis which normally can be shown experimentally later with an an accuracy of over 95 %.
See here also my views on the physical - the thermodynamics of death:
https://scientificlogic.blogspot.com/search?q=thermodynamics+of+death
References for Further Reading
Science and Cosmology
1. Cosmos – Carl Sagan
2. Astrophysics for People in a Hurry – Neil deGrasse Tyson
Physics and Theory
3. A Brief History of Time – Stephen Hawking
Philosophy of Mind and Consciousness
4. The Conscious Mind – David Chalmers
Theology and Spiritual Thought
5. The Bible (especially Genesis and the Gospel